Franklin Fired — Penn State’s Promising Football Season Crumbles

At the start of the 2025 college football season, the Penn State Nittany Lions stood at the No. 2 spot in the national rankings. Hopes skyrocketed and Beaver Stadium filled with fans in blue and white, ready to witness what was thought to be a championship run. Sports analysts predicted that this was finally the year — the year Penn State would bring the trophy home to Happy Valley. The talent was there. The momentum was there. The expectations were sky high.

But what was supposed to be a storybook season has quickly turned into something closer to a cautionary tale.

A Promising Start Meets Its First Test

The first major challenge of the season came on Sept. 27 against the Oregon Ducks (No. 6 at the time). It was a game that had viewers on the edge of their seats: Two top 10 teams, who competed against each other at nationals the year prior, stood toe-to-toe.

During four quarters and two overtimes, both teams traded blows. But in the end, Oregon edged out Penn State 30–24, handing the Nittany Lions their first loss of the season. The mood after the game wasn’t panic — at least not yet.

Fans and analysts agreed. A close loss to a top 10 team on the road wasn’t a death sentence for playoff hopes. But what no one knew was that this was just the beginning of the collapse.

A Shocking Domino Effect

The following week, the Lions faced the UCLA Bruins, a team that had opened the season with a dismal 0–4 record and was ranked among the bottom 10 teams nationally. For many, it was expected to be a bounce-back game. Instead, it became the season’s turning point.

In a shocking upset, Penn State lost to UCLA. This loss hit Penn State fans harder than a linebacker on third and long, leaving everyone saying, “How the hell did this happen?”

UCLA was just the second domino in the line of Penn State’s fall. The game against the Northwestern Wildcats was the third time where Penn State once again came up short. What had started as a promising year was quickly turning into a nightmare.

Key Pieces Fall Apart

The on-field struggles were compounded by devastating personnel losses. Star quarterback Drew Allar, the offensive centerpiece and a Heisman hopeful, suffered a season-ending injury (As if the losses weren’t season-ending enough.)

But the most shocking blow came from off the field. Head coach James Franklin, who had been with the program for over a decade and was under contract through 2031, was fired following the Northwestern loss. The buyout? Nearly $50 million.

The decision sent ripples through college football. Firing a high-profile coach mid-season is always dramatic, but doing so just weeks after starting the year ranked No. 2 was almost unheard of.

It’s not just the losses, it’s the manner of those losses. A team that looked like a playoff contender fell apart faster than anyone could have imagined.

Instead of counting down the weeks to the College Football Playoff, fans are left watching a program try to pick up the pieces. Recruiting battles have grown tense, boosters are restless and the national conversation around Penn State has shifted from title contender to program in crisis.

Looking Ahead

There’s still time for the Nittany Lions to salvage some dignity this season, but the championship dreams that defined the preseason are long gone. The program faces a crossroads: rebuild and regroup, or risk falling farther behind in an increasingly competitive college football landscape.

For now, the number next to their name in the preseason rankings is nothing but a haunting reminder of how quickly everything can change.

Did Franklin deserve to be fired? Tag @VALLEYmag on Instagram or X with your thoughts!

Related